Spend the Lead on Safety: Biden AI Advisors Ben Buchanan & Tantum Collins on the Fate of the World
Hello, and welcome back to the Cognitive Revolution! You're hearing my AI voice clone today. I recorded this conversation from the car on a recent family road trip, and though I'm home now, I got sick, and I'd rather not delay the episode. My guests today say they are probably correctly identified as China hawks. From inside the Biden White House, they were part of the small group that pushed to cut China off from the most advanced AI chips. Yet both were also in the room when the United States sat down with the Chinese government to talk about AI safety. How those two things fit together is the heart of this conversation. They are Ben Buchanan and Tantum Collins, who goes by Teddy, and their new book is The Bitter Struggle. It chronicles how they made the case in government that AI would become central to national security, and works through the hardest dilemmas it creates. And while they insist that democracies must lead, they also write that no single nation can manage this alone. Their theory of the case is this. Because the US and its allies control the supply chain for advanced chips, we can deny China computing power and build a lead, without racing recklessly ourselves. Then, in the phrase they used in government, we "spend that lead on safety." By Ben's estimate, we still have something like a hundred to one advantage in producing computing power, and probably fifteen to one in access to it. So the lead exists. My question is whether we know how to spend it. It's been ten years since OpenAI showed a boat-racing agent spinning in circles, crashing over and over to rack up points, and we still don't have a good solution to reward hacking. I also pushed on the "better us than them" framing. In some ways the US is starting to look more like China, in exactly the ways we say are bad. Teddy's response is that democracies have corrective mechanisms that autocracies lack, and that over the long run, concentrated power tends to end badly. I think that's pretty much indisputable. But I still worry about how our strategy looks to China. When I visited this summer, people told me the US is just trying to hold them down. What I call the Dario plan, from Dario Amodei's essay Machines of Loving Grace, is to build a big coalition, box China out, and eventually make them an offer they can't refuse. From Beijing, I think that could easily read as a second century of humiliation. Ben made a point of saying that's Dario's essay, not theirs. The model he prefers is America at its best after World War Two, building institutions that ceded some of its own power, and that other countries, China included, could join without regime change. That struck me as notable, given the close ties I understand Anthropic to have had with the Biden administration, and that Ben now advises Anthropic. My own view is that the real aliens here are the AIs, not the Chinese. I'd rather take my chances on cooperation than try to shoot the gap, building just enough of a lead and solving safety just in time. My shorthand for the deal I'd want is "chips for controls." Ben's reply is that they tried. When the two sides met in Geneva in May of 2024, by his account, the Chinese delegation treated talk of shared AI risk as "some kind of plot." Chips for controls, he says, is the end game. What they heard was, "sell us chips," and we can talk about the rest later. Then he turned the question on me. Would I sell China chips as a precondition for talks? It's a fair question, and you can judge how well I answered it. One thing I have to take on board is that they tried, and found little interest. That sucks. But I suspect it might be different now, or very soon will be. Just as people who wrote off AI based on the original ChatGPT have no idea what they're missing, we should be very open to the possibility that the Chinese government will update its worldview and priorities in light of new developments. Finally, Teddy lays out what the book calls the Bitter Temptation. Even if we get everything else right, AI could make centralized administration so effective that democracies slowly creep toward autocracy on their own. I share his obsession with that question, and I've invited him back for a full episode. In the end, I heard more moderation than their reputation would suggest. Their chip policy is hawkish, but they really do want the two countries to work together where possible for the common good. They insist that China is no excuse to race ahead dangerously, and that if they were in power today, they would keep trying to reach the Chinese government. I was heartened to hear that, and I hope the current administration follows their lead. With that, I hope you enjoy this conversation about compute, China, and what it would really take to spend a lead on safety, with Ben Buchanan and Tantum Collins, co-authors of The Bitter Struggle.
Watch now!
Thank you for being part of The Cognitive Revolution,
Nathan Labenz